|
In Portrait of Hemingway, Lillian Ross describes her
trip to the Metropolitan Museum of Art with Ernest Hemingway
and his son, Patrick. After looking, for several minutes,
at Paul Cezanne's painting, Rocks-- Forest of Fontainebleau,
Hemingway states, "This is what we try to do in writing,
this and this, and the woods, and the rocks we have to
climb over. Cezanne is my favorite painter, after the
early painters. Wonder, wonder painter" (60). Cezanne
had a significant influence on Hemingway and his writing.
This influence has been acknowledged in Hemingway's own
work as well as in various interviews and articles. Hemingway
was introduced to Cezanne's work in the rue de Fleurus
studio during his regular visits to Gertrude Stein when
she served as a mentor to him. There were two of Cezanne's
paintings in the studio, and Stein had her own "indebtedness"
to Cezanne involving her theories of structure in writing.1
Cezanne was practically a hero to Hemingway who wanted
to "write stories as objective and real as the paintings
of Cezanne, to do the country as Cezanne had done it."2
Neither Hemingway nor Lillian Ross ever gives any explanation
as to what "this and this, and the woods, and the
rocks we have to climb over" means. It is never explained
what, in the painting, it is he is referring to. What
is it, exactly, that we "try to do in writing?"
What is it about Cezanne's work that allows Hemingway
to point at a canvas and, for all practical purposes,
say, "this is the way I strive to write?"
Rocks-- Forest of Fontainebleau is a landscape. Many connections
can be made between Hemingway's and Cezanne's treatment
of landscape. Emily Stipes Watts, in Ernest Hemingway
and the arts, names four main methods in Cezanne's painting
that Hemingway is able to transpose into words. The first
is the "use of a series of planes for depth and structural
development" (32). The second technique is that he
never allowed the distant mountains in a landscape to
become lost or "hazy" and was still able to
clarify their position in space. The third technique of
Cezanne's was his "emphasis upon volumes of space
with the use of simple geometrical forms as the basis
of definition." And, finally, Cezanne let color mold
and define form rather than light and shade (34).
Watts applies each of these to Hemingway's own description
of landscape. She explains that Hemingway's landscapes
exist as a series of spatial planes. She points out that
the while a writer may not be able to outline the distant
ridge of mountain with a paintbrush, Hemingway's "distant
mountains" maintain their position in space due to
his use of specific, contrasting color (34). Solidity
and volume, likewise, are of primary importance in Hemingway's
landscapes. Lastly, Watts argues that Hemingway rarely
describes his landscape in terms of light and shade, but
utilizes color, just as Cezanne does (35).
Hemingway and Cezanne's affinity, however, cannot lie
solely in artfulness of landscape description. There must
be something more significant underlying the careful craftsmanship
of each artists' landscape. Hemingway's landscape, of
course, is heavily nuanced with something else, a something
more. According to Watts, the "something more"
that they share within these four techniques, points to
a permanence or an order or form outside of man --the
absence of chaos.3 This link is important but, perhaps,
it is limiting to only link these two masters by landscape.
|